Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Sonic...Not So Universe (rant warning ahead! Zoooom)

Update 2 for the birthday week is up.
The update had a scattering of things, as usual and did help to clear up some of the mail. One of the things that had been pending for a long time though, was an update to the Archie section. Since that stuff doesn't eliminate mailed in items it kept getting put off. This update had issue 200 of the main series and #4 of Sonic Universe. Another update to the section won't be required until something else happens, so that's fine too.
Sonic a Universe of Dissapointment-?
As you well know the PREMISE for SU was good. Wrap up the Sonic X plot and then take off into uncharted and all new territory based on the games and starring multiple characters. This was a great idea for several reasons:
Sonic X itself was doomed to end/be finite.
The comic COULD NOT cover what all happened in the show past a certain point because "Its not appropriate for 5 year olds". Also, the show itself was finite too, with a beginning, middle and end. There's only so long that anyone could mess around doing side stories and things like that before the material would run out and you'd start bumping into the "Walls" set by the chosen continuity. It's *perfectly OK for the comic to end*

Different Characters are cool:
Knuckles the comic couldn't sustain itself, though it was the most successfull of the Sonic Spinoffs. Tails' series failed due to miserable art and a worse story. Sally's series didn't go full-time, likely due to lack of Sega fueled fan support but no one will really ever know the answer to that one, as it WAS well plotted and pretty well drawn too.

However, people DO like Shadow, Knuckles, Blaze, Marine, Amy, Tails, and probably everyone except maybe Big. Do they like them enough to sustain a billion sepearate series every month? Not likely. But THATS the beauty of something like that! You get BREIF periods focusing on the characters. It's enough to satisfy the fans of each one without having to go overboard. Brilliant move. It could go 'round robin' for basically ever, to satisfy everyone. And you know people would still collect the books for the other chars plus their fave too.
Archie out of the equasion:
It's no secret that the main Sonic book has a rep for being "newbie unfriendly" due to its really convoluted nature, abandoned plot points galore and tons of filler characters being unloaded left and right. The cast is way up in the 100s and there's nothing they're going to do about that. That's FINE. Archie Sonic has it's niche among collectors and old-line fans who are all into (or at least dont mind) all the klutter and complexity it provides.

With Universe, it was said to be able to not have that Archie-centric focus where it baffles newcomers. Use the games, use the Sega cast which is now pleeeenty big enough to do pretty much anything. Invent a new villain for the Chaotix? Cool. What would Knuckles do in the event of a natural disaster somewhere? I don't know. What's Shadow up to lately? People might like to know. Bring Sonic in on some of them, leave him out of others. There's plenty to be messed around with...without dipping into archie confusion zone. Again, good idea.

Too bad they used HARDLY ANY of the stuff above.

Sure they said they would, but after Book 4, the whole mess is in the dumpster! The 4th issue even dredged up the absurd Feist and plunked him in. (Yeah I'm sure the Chaos emeralds if they weren't produced by purely natural sources would have been made by something other than a giant stupid panda bear. You couldn't come up with something cooler? That was genuinely god-like and not petty AND naive? Really?)

So, I was like 'ok yeah you can recycle a villain/whatever or 2 out of Archie.' The book will still be fine. They explain him well enough without having to sit in expo-mode for half an hour and you're not baffled by anything other than his dumbness.

The next 4 issues, look out!
It's a return of the dreaded "Future Comic". They say 'popular demand' but WHO THE HELL IS DEMANDING THIS? (I want to throw something at you, if its true. Maybe a stapler.) I can't IMAGINE who is wanting more of this trash! Sonic fans? WHY?

(more on that later)
FutureFAIL is an immideate dip into the Archieverse bucket that will totally alienate anyone who liked the concept of Universe! Infact, it's the WORST move they could make on the book because that futuretown BS brings in the worst of archieverse in the fastest way possible. Billion mile long family trees for Knuckles! Echidna society that's totally archiverse created and goes with no show or game ever! Do you know who the dingoes are? Do you want to? Stupid characters by the handfull that no one's ever seen before! Mary Sues galore! It has nothing to do with anything and they're moooovin on in on the SECOND arc? Really now? If you're going to churn out a stinker like that at least shovel that swill in up after issue 10 unless you're TRYING to kill the book early! Way to take everything you promised and throw it in the bin, people!

If you don't know: Why is it a bad idea?

It's set 20 years in the future. Sonic & co. are all adults, married with children. Yes that's exactly what teens and tweens and kids like to read about. Married old couples raising their kids! Wait...no.

They'll have to spend half the books in exposition mode to fill in all the people they hopefully attracted over from Sonic X. This will bore anyone else. If you liked X, you're not going to want to re-learn everything from archie because there was....A REASON you didn't collect Archie!

To 'get' futuretown you have to 'get' all the stuff from archieverse past and all their billions of dudes. There's no way they're going to even be able to explain it well enough in expo mode even if they waste half the comics doing so. Their expo mode wont even work.

It's going to look 'shoveled in'.

You just came off a decent Team Dark/Shadow story and now instead of more 'current events' you get some irrelevant to everything X and Universe-so-far plot. Woo. Suddenly jumping into a hypothetical 100% Archie only mess is really WTH.

In conclusion:
If Universe is able to weather this storm of crazy, AND they actually return to their original game plan, it should likely turn out ok. Here's to hoping they remember it, or they get hit by enough 'fan mail' that the whackin' helps remind them of what they promised.

Ok opinion time...beware below:

Futuretown is horrible and I hate it because:

It's billed as a 'possible future'-
That means its an excersize in futility to even focus on it. Someone can write in 'o wait no that never happened'...and so it didn't. Plot abandonment ahoy. Free reign to just dither and act bogus and do whatever the hell...it doesn't matter! Throw in any filler garbage you can find. There's no real 'investment' anyone wants to make in the futuretown arcs either on the reading end or the writing end because they are FAKE.

Their 'kids' are stupid-

Yeah I'm sure if you got a cat and a dog to mate that it would have 2 puppies and 2 kittens and you wouldn't get some cat-dog hybrid things. DUR everybody knows that since kindergarden. EVERYTHING mixes or it's just the most retarded thing in the world! ARGH. You can be 4 years old and know that things mix when you mix 'em! But no. They got a boy hedgehog and girl...whatever the hell Sally is this week. At least make the Sally creature blue! This is sheerly doofy and poor character design. Which brings it to...

STOP trying to replace Sonic!
They did it because the "kids" can be little clones of the parents that still aren't...and they can make those do whatever they want without the restrictions and expectations of Sonic characters. It's basically a totally un-creative way to make Sonic-clone fanchars that you can give whatever powers to that you want. It's like people who color Tails green and say he's Smails the schlox and he's JUST LIKE TAILS BUT..... (See what they are doing is cribbing off of characters that are actually cool because they can't make up a character that is actually cool on it's own merit. That would be difficult) It's not amusing in the damm fics and it's not any more amusing here. Shovel in the Mary Sues galore with the tykes! Don't focus on Sonic! Change Sonic in stupid rediculous ways...you can get away with it because it's "Hypothetical". Yeah Knuckles is so lame that I'm sure he'd falter in battle bad enough to have his eyeball torn out of his head. (it's missing in the futuretown) See?

I despise things that replace Sonic.

I am a Sonic fan who enjoys Sonic things. This is why I diss so much fic. The first thing so many authors do is have their sue come in and replace Sonic. That or be somehow just like Sonic but better. Why the hell did I come here? I came to read a story about chars I know, not about 50,000 made up dimwits with 900 powers each. So what their aim is in these futurestories is to replace Sonic & Knuckles with their kids. That look just like them but are better somehow (OMG that is so clever and not at all like Smails the schlox) Plus the Knuckles spawn is female so you can get in there some o' that good old "Well what if he was a girl...".

Sonic is cool BECAUSE he is a kid.

Yes yes opinion and all. But look at all the super heroes and stuff out there. Master Chief? I'll be it's a grownup in that suit. DC? Marvel? Grownups for the mostpart. Yeah there's the teen titans but they're not like...the be-all end-all of everything. It's unusual enough that he's a kid. Makes what he does more extraordinary. People turn to anime and manga because they're tired of the same ol' same ol'. Anime and manga can be wierd as hellz. And that's a good thing. He's a kid but he's not this cliche` RPG char type or a tries too hard to be cool sort. He's not an emo in highschool like a lot of the manga now either. He's not 'dark' and weighed down with 'emotional baggage' from the past. A real free spirit, like the wind you wish you could be.

And then he gets married and let them king him and has kids to watch and has to do what Sally says all the time and has baggage and the 'dark' and is weighed down by past events and...see? Not so pleasent. Stealing away the uniqueness. Would everyone be just as entertained by a story of Lara Croft where she's about 45 years old or so, married to some archaeologist dude and has to do what he says all day? As they have to watch their 3 kids in the back yard? Or how about some wacky adventure where her kids get into trouble and act smart-azz? No, she's not as entertaining in that scenario so everyone doesn't obsess over writing Lara: 20 Years later and married with kids and baggage!

The end.

Incidentally: Sonic can't lose an eye. All he has is one. Technically then he is a cyclops. How do the colored bits move independently of eachother. No one knows. This is still all right. If you made it down this far, you get a .gif.


Blogger JP Revan said...

i made that gif!

6:34 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home